[routing-wg] The dangers of demonizing bogons 2019-08 : (Fwd: [ncc-announce] [news] Sanctions and the RIPE NCC: Status Update)

Melchior Aelmans wrote on 24/06/2020 19:27:
> Although I see your concerns I don't agree that 2019-08 changes RPKI 
> from "opt-in" to "no opt-out". In fact, 2019-08 gives you options to 
> "opt-in" in multiple ways and so gives you options to choose from.

Network engineers see tools. Other people see big red buttons, itching 
to be pushed.

There's no shortage of people wanting these buttons to be created, e.g.

https://twitter.com/CarolineGreer/status/1268835511222894598

The further down this road we progress as a community towards making 
centralised black-holing via a single court order a feasible reality, 
the more difficult it will be to reverse out when we realise we've gone 
too far.

I do not support the proposal for this reason.

Nick