[routing-wg] The dangers of demonizing bogons 2019-08 : (Fwd: [ncc-announce] [news] Sanctions and the RIPE NCC: Status Update)

Hi,

26 juin 2020 01:22 "Nick Hilliard" <nick at foobar.org> a écrit:

> Melchior Aelmans wrote on 24/06/2020 19:27:
> 
>> Although I see your concerns I don't agree that 2019-08 changes RPKI > from "opt-in" to "no
>> opt-out". In fact, 2019-08 gives you options to > "opt-in" in multiple ways and so gives you
>> options to choose from.
> 
> Network engineers see tools. Other people see big red buttons, itching to be pushed.
> 
> There's no shortage of people wanting these buttons to be created, e.g.
> 
> https://twitter.com/CarolineGreer/status/1268835511222894598
> 
> The further down this road we progress as a community towards making centralised black-holing via a
> single court order a feasible reality, the more difficult it will be to reverse out when we realise
> we've gone too far.
> 
> I do not support the proposal for this reason.
> 

Same here: I don't support it, for the same reason.

mh

> Nick