[ripe-167] Impressions brought from Moscow meeting
Alexei Platonov plat at ripn.net
Wed Feb 18 20:43:57 CET 1998
According to Andrew Stesin: > On Wed, 18 Feb 1998, Alexei Platonov wrote: > > 1) There do exists some part of RIPE community (ISPs from Russia, > > Kazakhstan, Belarus and Ukraine - about 45) that is served by RosNIIROS. > ^ > only 1 LIR from Ukraine, though; > you are serving mostly Russian territory Of course, I'm not going to make some secret from the fact that these ISP mainly represent Russia. Only one remark: some of ISPs that have signed "Memorandum" (Relcom, Sovam, ...) serve the territory of FSU. > > > > As you can notice, these items follow two stages described in ripe-167. > > I still think that this document is reasonable as far as it reflects > > reality, though the argumentation is not fully adequate. > > A better document is badly needed, anyway -- don't you agree? > Of course, but I never insisted that ripe-167 gives all details. It's just some direction to move. The only question is: if we understand that the direction is right, shall we move or we need detailed plan from the beginning to the final? The main contradiction between our positions (if I understand) is that I prefer to move immediately, step by step, even if we have no detailed plan for all path. > > It seems to me, that the above text doesn't contrdict your position > > or I don't understand anything. > > We -- means you and me :) -- got some understanding, that's it. > > So would you mind reviewing my own answers (on your behalf) to my own > questions, please? > > > > > The only thing I insist: we need to begin _practical_ work, including > > > ^^^^ > > > Would you please mind clarifying in details: who "you" (see "we" above) > > > are? > > You answer should be: "we" means the community, represented > by the working group recently formed. Yes? you are right > > > > > I have to do something with the > > > > community that already gets service through RosNIIROS, > > > > > > Why do you think you *have to* do something? What's wrong > > > with current state of affairs? Why something should be > > > changed? > > Ok, let's consider the above 3 questions answered by you already. > You already have customers, you want to continue your > activities and expand them, and to survive financialy, and to increase > quality of service. Be it so. > > > > Why attempts to expand the scope of RosNIIROS IR > > > to adjucent countries? this last question is the most > > > interesting and important for me. > > And this one? am I right feeling that if you are serving > a single LIR in Ukraine, you feel that the whole > Ukraine should be served by you also? no. You again mix things. On the first step we give the _opportunity_ to be served in RIPE NCC office for all who prefer it. As for the second step, I repeat once more - it'not clear how to do, and with large probability it's not RosNIIROS that will be the base for RIR. As it was mentioned already, the optimal scheme is RNA. > > > > Ok, am I understabding correctly, that without getting > > > a "RIPE NCC" label on the frontdoor RosNIIROS can't increase > > > the quality of service it provides? and this is the one and > > > only real problem? > > And this question I'd like to ask: did you consider some ways > of increasing the quality of your service, other than > getting a "RIPE Office" and "RIR" label, but just remaining to > be RosNIIROS? I'm quite sure that without coordination with RIPE, both financial and organizational, it's impossible to do something reasonable. > > Best regards, > Andrew Stesin > > nic-hdl: ST73-RIPE > > > Best regards, Alexei Platonov
[ lir-wg Archives ]