[anti-abuse-wg] meeting minutes

Hi,

the meeting minutes are so vague and unclear that most people would have 
no idea what is discussed or what the issues are.  For instance, the 
issues include that there is no linkage between the EU privacy laws and 
the actions taken by RIPE.  The same goes for the so-called consensus 
process.  it is so vague and the issues are not spelled out so anyone 
can claim a "consensus" even though the issues were never really 
identified.

Also, there is a proposal to change the way abuse contacts are listed in 
the database.  however, there is no description as to what makes those 
contacts fundamentally different from other contacts as it relates to 
the law and the claimed "consensus".  The minutes seemed designed to 
make sure outsiders have no idea what is going on.

It is interesting to note the ".ro" database that claims technical 
contacts cannot be revealed because it is protected by a specific 
privacy law.  they also claim "copyrights" on the data even though 
copyrights do not cover lists of facts like whois data.

Thank You
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: </ripe/mail/archives/anti-abuse-wg/attachments/20120612/5b6d9fa4/attachment.html>