[members-discuss] Yet Another Proposal for the Charging Scheme 2012

Hiya @everyone,

I hope I didn't miss any of the last 108 E-Mails came through the 
mailing list these days.
The current issues are concerning the charging scheme and the budget.

Regarding the charging scheme, as I understood the RIPE NCC was 
interested in a "per IP"
billing base, but this can't be done easily without risk due to tax issues.

I hope no one proposed it yet and I didn't see it, so I don't bother 
people with my email
now having a already existing proposal ;)

In my opinion, the most fair solution for everyone would be if the RIPE 
removes the category
based charging scheme and makes one member fee for everyone. Something 
like 500 EUR.
Then there are no tax issues anymore, because RIPE takes a membership 
fee, so it has members.

Additionally to this 500 EUR "base fee", every resource will be billed 
additionally, like currently
with the IPv4-PI. I think that would solve all problems and we get our 
fair "per IP (resource)" billing.

Something like:

ASN = 50 EUR
IPv4-PI /24 = 50 EUR
IPv4-PI /23 = 100 EUR
IPv4-PI /22 = 200 EUR
IPv4-PI /21 = 400 EUR
IPv4-PI /20 = 800 EUR
[...]
IPv4 alloc /22 = 50 EUR
IPv4 alloc /21 = 100 EUR
IPv4 alloc /20 = 200 EUR
IPv4 alloc /19 = 400 EUR
IPv4 alloc /18 = 800 EUR
IPv4 alloc /17 = 1.600 EUR
[...]
IPv6 alloc /32 = 100 EUR
[...]


So, a LIR with a /17 IPv4 alloc, a /32 IPv6 alloc, a ASN and a /24 PI 
for his customer will pay 2.200 EUR.
500 EUR membership base fee + 1.600 EUR /17 alloc + 50 EUR ASN + 50 EUR 
/24 IPv4-PI.

I just wrote some numbers down, without actually calculating a real 
price per allocation. The real prices
have to be calculated based on the budget. But in my opinion this is the 
most fair way to bill its members.
So everyone gets billed for the resources the he/she uses.

Our own category wouldn't actually change with the proposal from RIPE, 
but still I'm concerned regarding
our community.

Cheers,
Sven


--
Sven Wiese
CEO

I.C.S. "Trabia-Network" S.R.L.
[t] +373 (22) 844-844
[e] s.wiese at trabia.net <mailto:s.wiese at trabia.net>
[i] www.trabia.net <http://www.trabia.net>

Privileged/Confidential Information may be contained in this message. If 
you are not in the addresses indicated in this message (or responsible 
for delivery of the message to such person), you may not copy or deliver 
this message to anyone. In such a case, you should destroy this message 
and kindly notify the sender by reply e-mail.

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://www.ripe.net/ripe/mail/archives/members-discuss/attachments/20111006/b4d002df/attachment.html>