[ipv6-wg] Have we failed as IPv6 Working Group?

> Job Snijders wrote :
> I've observed IPv6 hitting a plateau (even a slight decrease!) in usage
> of IPv6 across multiple large networks measured over significant time.

I was expecting more than not even 3% IPv6 at AMSIX. I don't call it "significant time" yet.
IMHO, it will take a few more years before we get a clear picture.
IPv6 will plateau, I just don't think we know where and when yet. Or do we ?

> However, if IPv4 and IPv6 grow at the same rate, my interpretation would be that IPv4 use is not declining,
> thus IPv6 isn't growing, and we should indeed be discussing the current failing of IPv6.

I did not start this thread, but it is time to acknowledge that talks of 100% IPv6 are not something that should be on the table at this time.

> ps. Before we venture into a tit-for-tat where we trade pictures of decline (e.g. IXP stats) against pictures
> of growth (google stats), I'd like to learn more why we see what we see in the current decline graphs.

Do you measure what is happening on private interconnects ? MMR traffic ? I would guess that a good part of the IPv6 traffic is between large players, and that somehow they may have changed their peering scheme ?

Michel.