[anti-abuse-wg] 2019-03 and over-reach

Hank Nussbacher wrote on 23/03/2019 17:23:
> Purity of concept will result in massive gov't intervention since we 
> will have shown that we don't know how to self-regulate.
> The voices are already there:
> https://hackernoon.com/why-the-internet-must-be-regulated-9d65031e7491
> If you have an alternative solution, not even a better one, please 
> suggest it.

There is no quick or single solution because this is a complex problem 
which involves people and peoples' interactions with the internet.

MANRS is beginning to make a difference and will continue to gain support.

Several of the major global IXPs have implemented strict route-server 
filtering over the last 12-18 months.  There is a good deal of pressure 
being put on transit service providers to implement prefix filtering on 
their customer network handoff points.

RPKI adoption is now taking off in a big way - see AT&T's recent 
announcement and NTT's plans.  Commoditisation of RPKI support for IXP 
route servers will be available within weeks.

RPKI will help a good deal, and it shows more promise than IRR DB based 
filtering due to long term quality issues with IRRDBs in some areas 
(e.g. US, LATAM).

Nick