[address-policy-wg] unacceptable conduct and ad-hominem attacks

On Wed, Oct 19, 2016 at 3:19 PM, Jim Reid <jim at rfc1035.com> wrote:

>
> > On 19 Oct 2016, at 12:34, Ciprian Nica <office at ip-broker.uk> wrote:
> >
> > But my problem at this point is not with an idea being right or wrong
> but with the fact that you are not a fair arbitrer.
>
> In your (utterly flawed) opinion.
>
> I respect everyone's opinion and especially yours.


> I’m fairly sure the overwhelming majority of the people of this list have
> absolute confidence in the integrity of the WG’s co-chairs. If you think
> you can do better, feel free to stand the next time the appointment process
> runs.
>
> I never care about the majority and I don't think that should be a
standard. Time has proven that sometimes majorities are wrong.


> > As a WG Chair my opinion is that you should not take sides.
>
> There is no evidence whatsoever to support your claim that Gert (or
> Sander) are “taking sides”.
>

Supporting an idea and ignoring someone based on personal feelings means
taking sides.



> > It's a simple question from a member of the community to one of the WG
> Chairs: did you abuse the last /8 or not ? Do you consider yourself a
> neutral arbitrer or not ? Do you consider yourself the one that should be
> judging others ?
>
> Here’s a simple rhetorical question for you. Do you think making
> unjustified ad-hominem attacks and insults like the above will encourage
> support for your position on this policy proposal?
>
> Your behaviour here is unacceptable and way, way, way out of line.
>
> With power comes responsibility. And yes, we should question our "leaders"
all the time. This is not something wrong, it's helpful for keeping the
balance.



> > Or is it your "job" to shut the voices that are not according to your
> interests ?
>
> No. That’s *my* job. :-)
>
> Until you apologise and learn how to conduct yourself properly on this
> list, Ciprian SHUT UP.


Unsubscribe, shut up, go away... Next time you'll send me to a
concentration camp ? No I WILL NOT SHUT UP ! I will always express my
opinion even if I'm the only one in the world supporting it. A great
romanian said that the best definition of democracy is "I will fight till
my last drop of blood so you will have the right to disagree with me".

I know many don't like it and prefer to solve matters by putting the fist
into minority's mouth. Who'll be next in line to be "killed" tomorrow ?

Ciprian
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: </ripe/mail/archives/address-policy-wg/attachments/20161019/70a5368c/attachment.html>