[address-policy-wg] [ncc-services-wg] Crimea papers

Max, I also wish to know if such scheme is available for Crimea then...
May I send such papers for Ukrainian service region which was signed by 
i.e. Panama authorities? Why not? It is the same.

-- 
Dmitriy Zemlyanoy. DeltaHost.
http://deltahost.com

Max Tulyev писал 2014-07-28 21:26:
> Hi Gert,
> 
> for my knowlege, there was NO democratic decision, at least becuse of
> all international observers (excepr Russian, of course) said the vote
> itself was totally fake, but I'm not about it now.
> 
> NO GOVERMENT IN THE WORLD, including Dutch one, accepted Crimea is a
> part of Russia. So why RIPE NCC does?
> 
> If papers issued by Russian goverment in Crimea is acceptable because 
> it
> is good for some members, can RIPE NCC accept same papers issued in
> Crimea say Principality of Sealand goverment as well?
> 
> And the main question: Has RIPE NCC legal rights to accept that kind of
> documents at all? What RIPE NCC lawyers say?
> 
> On 28.07.14 21:04, Gert Doering wrote:
>> Hi,
>> 
>> On Mon, Jul 28, 2014 at 08:57:12PM +0300, Max Tulyev wrote:
>>> So RIPE NCC accepts Russian authorities have rights in Crimea region,
>>> i.e. accepts Crimea is a part of Russia?
>> 
>> Max, what are you trying to achieve?  There is no good answer to that
>> question.
>> 
>> Depending which media outlet you decide to believe, crimean people 
>> decided
>> to be part of Russia all on their own (which sounds quite legit to 
>> me),
>> in a democratic decision - or it was an annection by Russia (not 
>> overly
>> legit, but has happened in the past).  This is not something the RIPE 
>> NCC
>> can solve, and I think Axel's answer was as salomonic as possible: the 
>> NCC
>> serves it's *members*, not any government in particular.
>> 
>> Gert Doering
>>         -- NetMaster
>>