[address-policy-wg] [Ticket#2012092701011684] FW: Sub-allocations - fast and simple re-using IP-addresses

Dear Sander,

> But exactly the same can happen with sub-allocated address space. Why would
> transfers be any different? At least with a transfer you can show that the
> responsibility for those addresses was (temporarily) transferred to another
> organisation. With sub-allocated addresses the responsibility remains with
the
> original holder, who would then probably even have a bigger problem
explaining
> everything and getting off the spam lists.

> This seems to be an argument *in favour* of using temporary transfers...

It is very difficult discuss with black lists delisting. Some of black lists
can ignore requests. 

It is better prevent blacklisting.

If I understund well policy of transfers - minimal term of transfer - 2 years.
It is too long too. I understund that it is normail for EU, but for Russia
most of agreement usualy for 1 year.

--
Kind regards,
Alexey Ivanov
LeaderTelecom B.V. Team

URL: [1]http://www.LeaderTelecom.nl/ - IP- addresses
URL: [2]http://www.GetWildcard.com/nl - WildCard SSL certificates

14.10.2012 16:23 - Sander Steffann написал(а):
 Hi,

> > > Permanenent transfer cost [...]
>
> > Please remember that the current transfer policy explicitly states "This
> > re-allocation may be on either a permanent or non-permanent basis." so you
can
> > already use the current transfer policy for temporary transfers.
>
>  After temporary transfer you can receive back IPs which listed in
Spamhouse. I don't know any company which will temporary transfers IPs.

But exactly the same can happen with sub-allocated address space. Why would
transfers be any different? At least with a transfer you can show that the
responsibility for those addresses was (temporarily) transferred to another
organisation. With sub-allocated addresses the responsibility remains with the
original holder, who would then probably even have a bigger problem explaining
everything and getting off the spam lists.

This seems to be an argument *in favour* of using temporary transfers...
Sander
 
 

[1] http://www.leadertelecom.nl/
[2] http://www.GetWildcard.com/nl
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: </ripe/mail/archives/address-policy-wg/attachments/20121014/b4a0f5e8/attachment.html>