[address-policy-wg] [Ticket#2012110601002595] Status of /24 PI IPv4 from last /8

Dear Nick,

> > We allow to use our PA space with any transit provider. So customers will
> > be provider independent.

> So what happens when your customer leaves or gets into a dispute with you?
> Is the PA assignment your IP address or theirs?

This is our PA. But why they will leave us if they have agreement only for
PA-space (without IP-transit)? I see only 2 cases - price or customer don't
need IPs and return back.

> If it's yours when they leave you, then it's not provider independent. This
> is the way that most LIRs operate: PA assignments are valid as long as the
> end user is a customer of the provider.  Once they move to another provider
> and stop taking services from you, then the address assignment is no longer
> theirs.
> This is what provider independent means.  Anyone can multihome a /24 from
> an allocated block, but it will still remain part of a PA allocation.

If customer will not pay to sponsoring LIR - RIPE will request IPs back too. 
I think using PA space is good option for now. And ASAP start use IPv6.

 -- 
  Alexey Ivanov
 
 
07.11.2012 18:06 - Nick Hilliard написал(а):
 On 07/11/2012 13:53, LeaderTelecom Ltd. wrote:
> We allow to use our PA space with any transit provider. So customers will
> be provider independent.

So what happens when your customer leaves or gets into a dispute with you?
Is the PA assignment your IP address or theirs?

If it's yours when they leave you, then it's not provider independent. This
is the way that most LIRs operate: PA assignments are valid as long as the
end user is a customer of the provider.  Once they move to another provider
and stop taking services from you, then the address assignment is no longer
theirs.

This is what provider independent means.  Anyone can multihome a /24 from
an allocated block, but it will still remain part of a PA allocation.

Nick

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: </ripe/mail/archives/address-policy-wg/attachments/20121107/a039786e/attachment.html>