Latest and hopefully last iteration of ripe-81++

 Jessica Yu <jyy at merit.edu> writes:
  * Tony,
  * 
  * Thanks for the sending out the draft.  Does not have time to read the whole
  * thing yet but just for the certain parts I read, have a couple of comments:
  * 
  * 1. On page 52, interas-out definition: the order of announce and <metric> a
  * re
  * reversed.  It is just a typo I think since in interas-in, you have the righ
  * t
  * order.  So please change to:
  * 
Yeah - thats a typo.

  *     Format:
  *           to <aut-num> <local-info> <metric> announce <routing  pol-
  * 				    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~	 	
  *           icy expression>
  *   
  * 2. In interas-out the <metric> is optional, please mention that in the doc.
  *    interas-in is fine with <pref> being mandatory.
  * 

Okay - but I saw no mention of this in your proposal.

  * 3. In both interas-in and interas-out, <local-info> should be optional.
  * 
Why ? - does it harm to have it non optional - doesn't this cause problems
for your parser ?????
Again no mention in your original.

  * 4. See some misunderstanding about the pref-type and pref.  We may not writ
  * e it
  * clearly in our paragraph to you.  Can we discuss it face-to-face at the iet
  * f? 
  * 
If you think we can reach an understanding yes.

	-T



-------- Logged at  Thu Jul 21 20:29:33 MET DST 1994  ---------