This archive is retained to ensure existing URLs remain functional. It will not contain any emails sent to this mailing list after July 1, 2024. For all messages, including those sent before and after this date, please visit the new location of the archive at https://mailman.ripe.net/archives/list/[email protected]/
[atlas] Ability to traceroute to 240/4 - software vs. hardware probes
- Previous message (by thread): [atlas] Apologies for OOO reply
- Next message (by thread): [atlas] Probe 24434 down but pingable
Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ]
Seth David Schoen
schoen at loyalty.org
Mon Dec 26 23:51:17 CET 2022
Hi! I noticed that Phillip Homburg merged a RIPE Atlas client patch in November of last year, based on our request, that removes the Atlas probe's inability to test addresses in 0/8 and 240/4. https://github.com/RIPE-NCC/ripe-atlas-probe-measurements/commit/59475f848b2e55fa14f6c43e62557b97ed005241 So, I just tried a couple of measurements to 240.1.2.3 to see how Atlas would handle them: https://atlas.ripe.net/measurements/48100582/ https://atlas.ripe.net/measurements/48100585/ (I don't expect these to succeed, as no part of 240/4 is publicly announced in BGP; the interesting information to be garnered from this isn't whether the probes succeed, but how they fail.) For the first measurement, with ping, 6 hardware probes and 4 software probes all gave the same result: "Unreachable" (which is what you would get if you ran this on any ordinary Internet host with command-line ping). For the second measurement, with traceroute, 6 hardware probes all actually attempted the traceroute (getting failures after some small number of network hops), while 3 software probes all reported back "!address not allowed". What could account for the difference in how hardware and software probes handle this task? I would have thought that the change from last November would make software probes willing to attempt these.
- Previous message (by thread): [atlas] Apologies for OOO reply
- Next message (by thread): [atlas] Probe 24434 down but pingable
Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ]