[ncc-services-wg] Transfers from Ukraine, how to ideed protect resource holders

I support this.

27.10.22 20:58, Vitaly Zubok пише:
> 
> On behalf of UA.VISTI (LIR est. 1997, Kyiv, Ukraine) I have to tell that 
> we can't support neither banning of IP transfers from Ukrasinian LIRs 
> nor including any UA Government institution into process of transfer 
> approval. In our opinion them cannot serve the aim declared by authors 
> of such initiatives.
> 
> Instead, taking onto account the Russian aggression and that there are 
> Ukrainian territories _temporarily_ occupied by enemy forces which 
> widely use terror and robbery, RIPE NCC should consider additional due 
> diligence procedures approving transfers from Ukrainian LIRs.
> 
> These procedures should be discussed, but they should remain possible in 
> our realities.
> The disclaimer about possibility of transfer reversion offered in 
> [Protecting Resource Holders in Distressed Areas] seems reasonable, 
> however bona fide buyers might avoid additional risk of such situation 
> and choose not to deal with UA IP address blocks.
> 
> What would be offered instead: transfer request might be precessed by 
> several-step verification, and one of the steps, for example, might 
> include geolocation verification of the person submitting the request 
> (presuming that there are definitely non-occupied and non-combat areas 
> where Ukrainian governance  carried out in full, so  such person is not 
> unburdened by the circumstances of the war).
> 
> Regards,
> Vitaly Zubok
> Deputy Director
> 
> ELVSITI Information Center
> Kyiv, Ukraine
> +380442399091
> http://visti.net
>