[ncc-services-wg] RIPE Database Proxy Service Issues

On 02/01/2013 15:57, Axel Pawlik wrote:
> RIPE NCC offered to conclude the membership agreement for continuation
> of the service.
[...]
> The RIPE NCC asks that non-RIPE NCC member proxy service users become
> members but we propose to waive their membership fee until the discussion
> of the RIPE NCC Charging Scheme 2014 takes place.

Axel,

Thanks for your prompt reply and for providing an explanation of this decision.

I have no objection to requesting a contract for access to bulk data access
provided by the RIPE NCC.  I do, however, have a problem with:

-  the general concept of requiring RIPE NCC membership for services which
were previously available on a free-as-in-beer basis.

-  executive decisions being made which have a significant impact on the
RIPE community, and which are made without consultation with either the
RIPE NCC membership or the RIPE community.

The decision by the RIPE NCC board to require RIPE NCC membership for proxy
database access is not based on either a RIPE community or a RIPE NCC
membership mandate, and I'm surprised to find out about this decision on
nanog-l.  Can you please roll back this decision until we've had some
sensible debate on the matter,

thanks,
Nick
--
Network Ability Ltd.
ie.netability