[ncc-services-wg] Destruction of trust

At 17:51 19/07/2012 +0200, Sander Steffann wrote:
>Hi,
>
> > What shocked me when I got the attached template was how the English 
> was not grammatically correct and how unwilling the NCC was willing to 
> make any change to the template.
> >
> > Just taking section II:
> > II. The LIR made an appropriate control to the correctness of the 
> information provided by the Legacy Resource Holder and wishes to register 
> the Legacy Resources on their LIR account on behalf of the Legacy 
> Resource Holder.
> >
> > I had suggested the more correct form of:
> > II. The LIR has established the correctness of the information provided 
> by the Legacy Resource Holder and wishes to register the Legacy Resources 
> on their LIR account on behalf of the Legacy Resource Holder.
> >
> > but was turned down (as well as the 4 other changes I suggested to 
> sections 2+3).
>
>This is a different template than the one from RIPE-452. Are there 
>multiple EndUser<->LIR contract templates in use?

You can download it youself from:
http://www.ripe.net/lir-services/resource-management/legacy-space/template-agreement-between-legacy-holder-and-lir


> > This template was never brought to the membership, but is presented as 
> a "done deal" that every legacy holder has to sign.
>
>Yes, I can't remember any policy proposal that specified these 
>requirements. Where do they come from?

 From the RIPE site as listed above.

-Hank


>Thanks,
>Sander