[ncc-services-wg] Policy proposal for services to legacy Internet resource holders

On 23/08/2012 22:48, Nick Hilliard wrote:
> RIPE NCC rights:
> 	- the right to charge for RIR services over and above those listed by the
> proposal as ERX holder rights

Apologies, I omitted the following:

	- the right for the RIPE NCC to withdraw a basic service if and only if an
equivalent other service is provided, potentially charging the ERX holder
for the new service (section 5.1.2)

I think there may be a conflict in the proposal here between the proposed
rights of the ERX holders (i.e. the NCC must provide the basic services as
stated and must not coerce the ERX holder into paying in any circumstance),
and this suggestion (the RIPE NCC may completely withdraw a specific
service and replace it with something equivalent, and by doing so may
potentially coerce the ERX holder into paying for the new service).  Or did
I read it incorrectly?

Nick