[members-discuss] [RFC] Motion/Proposal for Amendments to RIPE NCC Charging Scheme 2025

Dear RIPE Members,

I am writing to propose amendments to the "RIPE NCC Charging Scheme
2025" for discussion. Below are the details of the proposed changes:

Proposal for a Proportional Charging Model:

We suggest that RIPE NCC implement a charging model based on the number
of IPv4 subnets allocated to each member. This model would replace the
existing flat fee structure, aiming to distribute costs more equitably
among members according to their usage of number resources. Such a
model would ensure that charges correspond to the scale of each
member's operations and resource needs.

Reduction of Annual Budget Based on Current Economic Trends:

Given the economic downturn affecting our industry, we recommend that
RIPE NCC conduct a thorough review of its annual budget to identify and
reduce non-essential expenditures. Prioritizing core activities is
crucial, especially in light of the decline in LIR membership numbers.
Adjusting budget allocations to current economic realities will help
stabilize the organization and alleviate financial pressure on its
members.

Furthermore, I have reviewed the archive and identified 41 unique email
addresses that participated in discussions about this charging scheme.
It appears that a consensus of at least 21 affirmative votes should
prompt RIPE NCC and the relevant working group to consider the
community's stance seriously.

Accordingly, I propose a motion to include the following options in the
charging scheme discussion:

A) Maintain the current budget.
B) Reduce the budget, possibly in proportion to the decrease in LIR
numbers.
C) Introduce fees for LIRs based on their allocated IPv4 resources.

I suggest conducting a non-binding poll to gauge preferences on these
options. While I am not authorized to initiate official voting,
gathering responses could help us understand whether the demand for
significant changes represents a majority view or just a few vocal
opinions.

Please reply to this email with your vote: YES or NO after each option.

Best regards,

Denys Fedoryshchenko