[members-discuss] RIPE NCC Charging Scheme 2025 Open House: Recording and Slides Available

On 11/04/2024, 15:16:25, sdy at a-n-t.ru wrote:
>It's wrong model with categories. It do not anything to decide resources
>deficits.
>It is strongly must be payment for each assigned deficit resource, like
>was the  land tax in England. Only this way making all NCC equal in their
>rights, and will return unused resources to NCC.

It would be wrong to base a model on resources being returned so
NCC can reissue for free. That is not likely to happen. The holders
will slowly release them to the market to avoid a price crash, like
housing suppliers do in England.

The market price may go down a little but generally there will
be an easy supply as there is already.

There is no shortage of v4, just a surplus of people wanting them
for free.

One day as v6 grows they may return v4 that people no longer need. It
is likely to be the larger providers that will do that first. Then
that charging model will collapse.

>WE need to vote at first MUST we pay for each deficit resource or not. And
>it NEED to take in vote all NCC members!

Be careful what you vote for, if the charge is per v4 then those
with the most will want more votes as they paid more and then they
can vote themselves a discount for those with lots.

brandon