[members-discuss] [Ticket#2012072401002498] Probably Free /8 networks in RIPE region

Dear Erik,

 > I spoke with someone from Surfnet a while ago (they also have a /8 and a
whole block of 16 bit ASN
> pre-RIPE) and on they question if they would return space to RIPE, their
answer was :
  > <quote>Why prolong the inevitable, we have been doing v6 for 15 years
already. Everyone should do
> the same ...</end quote>
> That reasoning is very true and I do agree with it.

Yes, from technical point of view it is excelent answer and probably ideal way
for internet. But when you goes to CFO and tell that you need new equipment -
he will ask reason why you need additional investments? All works well. You
can tell stories about IPv4 and IPv6... But from finance point of view it
doesn't make any sense. Run IPv6 and what next? It will give you new
customers? Or current cusomers will pay mode money? NOOOO! It is just extra
expenses. It time when each company try to cut costs impossible to invest
money in word "IPv6". But! If cost IPv4 will grow - then it will be very
simple for companies to understund that chaeper will be migrate to IPv6. 
   
  > That is also why a charging scheme based on v4 is short lived and
out-dated by the time it comes
> into action. The first RIPE invoice based on it, will be when the resource
pool is already in the final /8.
> And that pool won't magically grow back above it ... 
  > A charging scheme based on budget / nr of members is my prediction where
things should go for the
> above mentioned reasons, why based it on a resource or charge for a resource
that is gone ... To have
> this discussion again in one or two years ? Please spare me ... 

But RIPE must support servers, software and etc which support IPv4. And all
this expenses must pay LIRs? When IPv4 will finished and new LIRs will get
only IPv6 - why they must pay a huge money for support IPv4 when they will
provide only IPv6?
 
  --
Alexey Ivanov
LeaderTelecom Ltd.
 
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://www.ripe.net/ripe/mail/archives/members-discuss/attachments/20120727/8c549b99/attachment.html>