AW: AW: Deletion of .de domain objects

Hi,

you'll see the crippled data if you would look at the person-a nd
role-handles. Just comapre whois -h whois.ripe.net NOC54-RIPE with whois -h
whois.denic.de NOC54-RIPE.
The changes at the interface: i dont think of the whois-output here, what
is important is the change in update/create/delete-procedure.

Gruss

Henning Brauer
Hostmaster BSWS

------------------------------------------------
BS Web Services
Roedingsmarkt 14
20459 Hamburg
Germany

info at bsmail.de
www.bsws.de

fon: +49 40 3750357-0
fax: +49 40 3750357-5

PLEASE USE EMAIL WHERE POSSIBLE


                                                                                                                                
                    Nils Jeppe                                                                                                  
                    <nils at work.de        To:     henning.brauer at bsmail.de                                                       
                    >                    cc:     info at denic.de, lir-wg at ripe.net, NCC Network Coordination Center                
                                         <ncc at mediascape.de>, owner-loca-ir at ripe.net                                            
                    30.06.00             Subject:     Re: AW: AW: Deletion of .de domain objects                                
                    11:52                                                                                                       
                                                                                                                                
                                                                                                                                




On Fri, 30 Jun 2000 henning.brauer at bsmail.de wrote:

> Once again: We are not against moving domain-objects out of the Ripe-Db,
we
> could even live with the persons and roles in a DENIC-Database.

That is your right, however, it won't change a thing. ;-)

> But the way DENIC is doing the move, wirh cripled testing data in
> production, is not acceptable. The plan to let only members do changes is
> not acceptable.

Where do you see crippled data in denic's db? Report it to them as a
bug. When I look at our own main domain (work.de) the only thing I see is
a pretty ugly "changed" line, but that is hardly critcal.

> Nobody would say anything against moving all the stuff to the DENIC db if
> the interfaces won't change too much.

The interface didn't change a lot, the output of the whois db is pretty
much the same as with ripe db.

> The way this is done now means really hard life for small providers in
the
> future and tons of work (senseless work) now.

I completely fail to see the problem.




- ----------------------------------------------------------------- -
  n at work Internet Informationssysteme GmbH      Tel +49 40 23880900
  Spaldingstrasse 160d                          Fax +49 40 23880929
  20097 Hamburg, Germany                        http://www.work.de/