[ipv6-wg] Latest draft for RIPE554-bis

Tim*2, Sander, Jan, and Merike,

First of all, thank you for taking the pen to update this document. As you kindly asked for comments, here are some
- page 2: 'fairly recent' won't age well ;-)
- page 4: all requirements are limited to performance, but should it also include telemetry/monitoring ? Or is it implicit in the list of RFC ?
- page 4: what about systems to handle VMs and containers ?
- page 4: mobile devices have a *big difference* with normal host though as they often have multiple interfaces active at the same time.
- page 4: should we assume that Wi-Fi access points are 'normal layer-2 switches' ?
- page 6: I am surprised to see RFC 8415 DHCPv6 client as mandatory...
- page 6: if not mistaken RFC 8200 now includes RFC 5722 and RFC 8021 (so no need to add the latter in the requirements)
- page 7: same surprise to see all DHCP-related requirements
- page 7 and other: nice to list some MIB but I would expect some YANG modules as well for enterprise/ISP devices
- page 9: should Jen's RFC 9131 be added as optional ?

Hope this helps

-éric

PS: the attached PDF has the same comments in the text.

On 02/11/2021, 16:05, "ipv6-wg on behalf of Tim Chown via ipv6-wg" <ipv6-wg-bounces at ripe.net on behalf of ipv6-wg at ripe.net> wrote:

    Hi,

    Attached below is the latest draft for RIPE554-bis, the update to Requirements For IPv6 in ICT Equipment.

    The authors have incorporated feedback received on and off list, and believe the current draft is a candidate to be considered towards publication.  We have a slot in the upcoming RIPE meeting to present and discuss the latest changes, but further list feedback would be welcome now.   Is it ready to ship?  If not, why not?

    The original version can be found at https://www.ripe.net/publications/docs/ripe-554

    Best wishes,
    Tim

-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: RIPE554-bis-evyncke.pdf
Type: application/pdf
Size: 186639 bytes
Desc: RIPE554-bis-evyncke.pdf
URL: </ripe/mail/archives/ipv6-wg/attachments/20211105/271c0a60/attachment.pdf>