[ipv6-wg] Last Call (20101117): Requirements For IPv6 in ICT Equipment

On 9.11.10 4:29, Francis Dupont wrote:
>     We would appreciate if you let us know by the end of November 17, 2010 if
>     you have read the document and whether you support the publication of the
>     document.
>
> =>  yes

Hi,

Thnx for your support (for support from all of you :) )

>
>     As long as we get at least 8 statements of support and no significant issues
>     are raised, we will ask the RIPE NCC to publish the document after fixing
>     minor editorial issues (if found).
>
> =>  there is at least one error: IKEv2 relies on IPsec-v3 so it is not
> possible to require IPsec-v2 and IKEv2 with IPsec-v3 optional.
> There are two ways to solve this: make IKEv2 optional or IMHO far better
> swap IPsec-v2 and IPsec-v3.

Theoretically I agree with you. But we try not to currently exclude too much 
hardware.

What percentage of current equipment you can buy supports IPsec-v3 ?

>
> BTW I think the correct spelling for UPNP is UPnP (lower case 'n').

Will fix, thnx.

/jan