[dns-wg] Proposal: Charter for DN* wg at RIPE

Note: I want _LOTS_ of comments on the following. You will see after 
this a message about the agenda of the meeting at RIPE 46.

Idea: Create a list of "topics" which are divided in two groups:

   [1] Topics which are larger discussion items. Each one
       will have one or more deliverables. There is a small
       group of people responsible for deliverables and they
       report back every DN* meeting.

   [2] Organisations and groups (inside and outside of RIPE
       and RIPE NCC) which report to the DNS wg what is happening,
       what is currently discussed etc. This is summarized at
       every RIPE meeting as a compiled report to the RIPE DNS
       wg participants so they know what is happening in the world

The agenda at the RIPE meeting then consists of these two PLUS two 
other categories:

   [3] Invited longer talks

   [4] Short reports from groups which do not come back every meeting

The result from [3] and [4] is only included in the minutes of the RIPE 
meeting. Nothing more, nothing less.

Is that ok?


Given this is ok, the question is then what to include under each one 
of the bullets. This is (as you will see on the proposed agenda) what I 
want to have discussed at the RIPE meeting.

Below you can see _MY_PERSONAL_ idea. Probably many things forgotten, 
possibly many things wrong.

Please correct. Let me know you are interested in spending some CPU 
cycles.

Small things which will make the future more organized is that my goal 
is to keep exactly the same "item numbers" for every item, and never 
changing them over the years. That means the only topic I have got 
suggestions on (see below) is 1.1. Next will be 1.2. Etc.

       paf


Charter for the DN* wg at RIPE (to be updated at each RIPE meeting)
-------------------------------------------------------------------

[1] Topics with deliverables

1.1 Quality of the DNS

We have a few contributors here:

  + domainSentinel tool for lame checking
    Chagres Role Account <role at chagres.net>

  + RIPE NCC DNS Monitoring
    Daniel Karrenberg <daniel.karrenberg at ripe.net>

  + DNSCHECK for verification of delegations
    Patrik Fältström <paf at cisco.com>

Deliverables:

1.1.1 Recommendations for measures DNS serv*ice* quality

1.1.2 Recommendations how to summarise the results for consumption by 
the non-technical public

1.1.3 What is an "error"?

1.1.3.1 "Lame"
1.1.3.2 "Wrong glue"
1.1.3.3 "Non-authoritative response"
1.1.3.4 "Transport over TCP"
1.1.3.5 ...

1.1.4 What is good practice regarding measurement?

1.1.5 ...


[2] Reports / status items

  2.1 Monitoring
   2.1.1 RIPE NCC DNS Monitoring
         Daniel Karrenberg <daniel.karrenberg at ripe.net>

  2.2 DNS in the IETF
   2.2.1 DNSEXT
   2.2.2 DNSOP
   2.2.3 Other wg's which touch DNS

  2.3 EPP deployment / experience / status
      Edward Lewis <edlewis at arin.net>

  2.4 Root servers

  2.5 IDN deployment / experience

  2.6 DNSSEC deployment / experience

  2.7 Anycast deployment / experience
     2.7.1 Dave Knight
     2.7.2 I-Root (Lars-Johan Liman)

  2.7 CENTR Technical committee

  2.8 DNS Software
    2.8.1 Bind
    2.8.2 OpenReg
    2.8.3 ...

  2.9 IPv6 deployment / experience
      Unknown