[db-wg] proposal: disallow creation of new non-hierarchically named AS-SET objects

Cynthia Revström wrote on 29/11/2022 18:56:
> I agree with Nick.
> However there are currently as-set objects in RIPE based on aut-num
> objects in RIPE-NONAUTH.
> I think it might be worth considering if these should be cleaned up.
> I posted about this about a week ago in a separate thread on db-wg.

right, yes, you're correct.  I've included a list below.

The RIPE NCC can't stand over the authenticity of these objects because 
the AS in question isn't a RIPE-authenticated ASN. So RIPE-NONAUTH would 
be an appropriate place for them.

Changing this should not be service affecting, because the AS in 
question is already RIPE-NONAUTH.  Having said that, "should not" is not 
the same as "will not".

Some of these objects are stale.

Some of them are legacy resources, but can be subject to the same 
approach as defined in ripe-731.

Do we need a policy change to move these, e.g. similar to ripe-731, or 
simply including them in the scope of ripe-731?

Nick

--

AS702:AS-AT-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-BE-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-CH-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-CZ-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-DE-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-DK-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-ES-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-EURO-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-FI-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-FR-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-GR-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-HU-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-IE-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-IT-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-NL-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-NO-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-PT-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-SE-CUSTOMER
AS702:AS-UK-CUSTOMER
AS4004:AS-TO-AIX
AS9327:AS-HOPCOUNT
AS12041:AS-AFILIAS
AS12041:AS-PEERS
AS12041:AS-SET
AS12041:AS-SET:AS12287
AS12041:AS-SET:AS13714
AS12041:AS-SET:AS13901
AS12041:AS-SET:AS40490
AS12041:AS-TRANSIT
AS12287:AS-AFILIAS
AS13657:AS-EGATE
AS13657:AS-PEERS
AS13657:AS-TRANSIT
AS13714:AS-AFILIAS
AS13810:AS-AFILIAS
AS13901:AS-AFILIAS
AS17400:AS-CUSTOMERS
AS19551:AS-GLOBAL
AS20375:AS-CUSTOMERS
AS21003:AS-LTT
AS24115:AS-GENEVA
AS24115:AS-PARIS
AS24115:AS-ZURICH
AS26754:AS-PEERS
AS36692:AS-UMBRELLA
AS36925:AS-MEDI
AS36925:AS-PROVIDERS
AS36997:AS-TRANSIT
AS37002:AS-ALL
AS37012:AS-ALL
AS37133:AS-327707
AS37148:AS-GLOBACOM
AS37155:AS-PROVIDERS
AS37183:AS-SET
AS37284:AS-ALJEEL
AS37314:AS-CUSTOMERS
AS37314:AS-CUSTOMERS:AS328074
AS37314:AS-JINX
AS37314:AS-NAPAFRICA
AS37314:AS-NEOTEL
AS37314:AS-SEACOM
AS37366:AS-PROVIDERS
AS37558:AS-LITC
AS38193:AS-PEERS-RIPE
AS396071:AS-COMPLETE
AS396071:AS-CUSTOMERS
AS40490:AS-AFILIAS
AS55293:AS-A2HOSTING
AS58580:AS-ALL
AS62512:AS-CUSTOMER
AS135164:AS-PEERS
AS135183:AS-INSTALINKS
AS327717:AS-26754
AS327717:AS-26754:AS-328015
AS327717:AS-328015
AS327717:AS-328084
AS327938:AS-PEERS