[db-wg] ORG record vetting ?

 Hi Ronald
I have followed this whole discussion and it seems to be going round in circles. You have made a valid point, but the whole discussion seems to be focusing on the negative. Some people have referred you to a number of published documents about the due diligence process carried out by the RIPE NCC. It has been stated that, whilst it does not guarantee to perfectly vet all details, due diligence is a best effort.
We have reached a point in this discussion where perhaps you could read the suggested documents and if you believe there is something more than can be done realistically, practically and legally then please make a proposal for improving the RIPE NCC's due diligence process. Then we can turn this discussion into something more positive.
cheersdenis
co-chair DB-WG

    On Monday, 29 July 2019, 23:14:51 CEST, Ronald F. Guilmette via db-wg <db-wg at ripe.net> wrote:  
 
 In message <B83C8F8C-C5C3-4AAA-B00F-07EA193AB943 at foobar.org>, 
Nick Hilliard via db-wg <db-wg at ripe.net> wrote:

>On 29 Jul 2019, at 12:02, Carlos Fria=C3=A7as <cfriacas at fccn.pt> wrote:
>>
>> Perhaps excluding jurisdictions *outside* the RIPE NCC service region, where
>> company related data *can't* be verified by the RIPE NCC.
>
>The RIPE NCC doesn't claim verification. It only states due diligence.

For some reason, the above comment reminds me of this very old and tired joke:

    MAN:  "Doctor, doctor!  What's wrong with me?"

    DOCTOR:  "Well, you evidently have a broken leg."

    MAN: "I want a second opinion!"

    DOCTOR:  "OK.  Also, you're an idiot."

Sounds like due diligence of the doctor's part to me! :-)

But seriously, one man's due diligence may be another man's slipshod
pantomime.  And it is not clear, to me at least, what the precise
meaning of "due diligence" is in the context of RIPE NCC and the
parties it is alleged to "vet".

Traditionally, the term "due diligence" is used in the business world
to denote an investigation relating to a merger or acqusition.  And it
involves, quite certainly, a detailed examination of all financial and
bank records.  I rather doubt that RIPE NCC ever undertakes any such
invasive interrogations of any parties that are just trying to get
some number resources.  So in this context, "due diligence" must have
some rather different meaning, and NOT it's traditional meaning from
the world of mergers and acqusitions.

What that meaning actually is, and or what it should be, in this context,
is something that I personally think could benefit from some more detailed
elaboration than what currently seems to be publicly available.

But that's just my opinion.


Regards,
rfg
  
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: </ripe/mail/archives/db-wg/attachments/20190801/54a818b8/attachment.html>