[db-wg] out of region routing in the RIPE Database

 > I would like to have the IRR kept open, we have space from various
 > regions and need to be able to make use of a single well known IRR in
 > order to register our policies and be able to mix our ASNs with our
 > space.

There are non-RIR registries out there that can meet your requirement 
with out of region resources while not feeding RIPE DB with dummy objects.

Allowing object creation without authorization of the resources holder 
makes abuse much easier (DATASTAR-MNT is an example). It takes far more 
resources to shut down an abuser than abuser continuing with another 
mntner.

If an object already exists in a mirrored registry, RIPE dummy object is 
more likely to reduce the data quality (outdated/abandoned objects, 
conflicting information).

In short term (months), is there any logistical issue that prevents RIPE 
from implementing email authorization (aut-num PoC at issuing RIR) when 
creating an out of region object in RIPE DB? And if all non-RIPE address 
space were to be removed, what would be the timeline to stop accepting 
dummy objects?


Yang