[db-wg] History lost ...

Daniel, all

let me be very clear about one thing:
personally, I would also like to see the history of resource allocations.

But, there's (on top of the PII Data Protection) the contractual stuff
and the AUP.

If there's no longer a Service Contract in place and an object is
(voluntarily) deleted or the registration is removed by the RIR,
then the question may be raised:

° is that information still to be kept and made publicly available?

That's the reason why I think we should seek both:

- guidance or request by the community,
  and if requested (or maybe in parallel with the discussion)

- a review by the NCC's Legal Department.

Wilfried

On 2015-05-20 22:32, Daniel Suchy wrote:
> Hello,
> that's good point. But I have another - we still have major parts of
> RIPE database on FTP - ftp://ftp.ripe.net/ripe/dbase/ updated on regular
> basis.
> 
> If someone is smart enough to mirror these (public) data periodically
> (and anyone can do that), he's also possible to analyse history (with
> all "deleted" data).
> 
> Personal data aren't on FTP already - I think this is enough also for
> history publishing from RIPE DB history - as data protection is about
> *personal* data, in my oppinion. Historical data should ommit these pure
> personal details, but other (technical) history can be published.
> 
> With regars,
> Daniel
> 
> 
> On 19.5.2015 12:45, Wilfried Woeber wrote:
>> The Data Protection environment states that an organisation is not
>> supposed to collect data, or to keep storing it (and even less so,
>> making it publicly accessible!) unless there is a need to do so for
>> the declared reason, operation or goal.
>>
>> As the obejcts have been deleted, it can be inferred that there is no
>> longer a valid reason to store those items or to make them accessible.
>