Re: thoughts on updates for obj with guarded attribute

[Marten Terpstra <]

OK Wilfried,

One thing is an error here on our behalf, the other is correct in my view.

- error:
	192.108.151 is in the ACONET guarded file twice, which explains
	the duplicated ACONET in the bdrgw-l entry, this is a bug. If an
	entry appears twice in the same file, we should igore one entry.

- correct:
	You did NOT include the bdrygw-l field in your entry you sent in,
	so the software tells you it has added that line, which is correct
	in my view.

I will look at the error as soon as I can, probably after the IETF next week.
Maybe Daniel will have it fixed in the mean time.

Greetings from busy Interop,

-Marten


"Wilfried Woeber, UniVie/ACOnet" woeber@localhost writes
 * >
 * >Wilfried, if you still have the example you sent in, please forward it to u
 * s
 * >to see if we can reproduce and fix.
 * 
 * Here we go:
 * ...........................................................................
 * From:	ACCESS::WOEBER "Wilfried Woeber, UniVie/ACOnet" 30-SEP-1993 17:
 * 41:14.06
 * To:	RIPE-DBM
 * CC:	MX%"tkjg@localhost",MX%"pkl@localhost",WOEBER
 * Subj:	update connect: for CESNET-A in database
 * 
 * inetnum:   192.108.151.0
 * netname:   CESNET-A
 * descr:     Czech Educational and Scientific network
 * descr:     Prague
 * country:   CZ
 * admin-c:   Jan Gruntorad
 * tech-c:    Petr Kral
 * tech-c:    Jiri Orsag
 * tech-c:    Pavel Vachek
 * connect:   ACONET RIPE NSF
 * changed:   ors@localhost 930912
 * changed:   woeber@localhost 930930
 * source:    RIPE
 * ........................................................................... 
 * You see, there was no bdrygw-l: line.
 * This was the answer:
 * ........................................................................... 
 * Date: Thu, 30 Sep 1993 17:41:38 +0100
 * To: "Wilfried Woeber, UniVie/ACOnet" <Wilfried.Woeber@localhost
 * From: RIPE Database Management ripe-dbm@localhost
 * Subject: Re: update connect: for CESNET-A in database
 * 
 * Your e-mail:
 * 
 * >   From:    "Wilfried Woeber, UniVie/ACOnet" woeber@localhost
 * >   Subject: update connect: for CESNET-A in database
 * >   Date:    Thu, 30 Sep 1993 17:41:12 +0100
 * >   Msg-Id:  <00973541.749E8040.4828@localhost
 * 
 * has been processed by the automatic update procedure at the RIPE NCC.
 * Diagnostic output follows:
 * 
 * ------------------------------------------------------------------------
 * inetnum:   192.108.151.0
 * netname:   CESNET-A
 * descr:     Czech Educational and Scientific network
 * descr:     Prague
 * country:   CZ
 * admin-c:   Jan Gruntorad
 * tech-c:    Petr Kral
 * tech-c:    Jiri Orsag
 * tech-c:    Pavel Vachek
 * connect:   ACONET RIPE NSF
 * bdrygw-l:  ACONET ACONET
 * changed:   ors@localhost 930912
 * changed:   woeber@localhost 930930
 * source:    RIPE
 * WARNING:   guarded field bdrygw-l reset to current value
 * 
 * 
 * Objects that just generated a WARNING have been updated as shown.
 * [....]
 * ...........................................................................
 * Right now, reviewing it, I just notice that this was another instance where
 * I've seen duplicated bdrygw-l: flags. Maybe this can serve as a clue...
 * 
 * >Cheers from Interop,
 * 
 * Have a good time there,
 * cheers,
 * 
 * Wilfried.