[anti-abuse-wg] Proposal 2022-01

In message <alpine.LRH.2.21.2206231045180.15332 at gauntlet.corp.fccn.pt>, 
 =?ISO-8859-15?Q?Carlos_Fria=E7as?= <cfriacas at fccn.pt> wrote:

>> https://www.ripe.net/participate/policies/proposals/2022-01
>>
>> I suspect that many of you are going to want to read those sections before
>> you have your memberships revoked for non-compliance.
>
>I can't read any details about membership revokation. Also i don't see it 
>as implicit.

Well, I have been asking for various policies that would place some
restrictions on member conduct (in other context) for quite some
years now, and every time I have asked about such things, either in this
region (RIPE) or ibn other regions I have always been told "Sorry, no,
we can't do that because we have no enforcement mechanism and we have
no way to disipline members."

Any yet here we have a proposal that clearly intend to -force- members to
put accurate information into their WHOIS records.  This raises the obvious
question:  How?  How will members be forced into this, when it has previously
been asserted (in other contexts) that there never has been (and never will
be) any way to force members to do anything OTHER THAN to pay their RIPE
dues?

>The three sections make perfect sense to me. In section 6.0, if i 
>understood correctly this won't apply to legacy resources which are still 
>out of any contractual relationship -- which also seems fine.

That's not the way that *I* read it.


Regards,
rfg