[anti-abuse-wg] 2019-03 and over-reach

JORDI PALET MARTINEZ via anti-abuse-wg wrote on 23/03/2019 11:52:
> El 23/3/19 12:32, "Nick Hilliard" <nick at foobar.org> escribió:
>      1. it's not the job of the RIPE NCC to make up for a short-fall of civil
>      legislation in this area, no matter how distasteful we might find the
>      consequences of this;
> 
> And we aren't doing that.

If there were legislation and enforcement in this area, we wouldn't be 
having this conversation.

>      2. you can throw anything into a contract, but that doesn't mean it's
>      enforceable or even lawful. > [...]
>      In this particular case, the suggestion is for the RIPE NCC to start
>      making judgements about potentially legal actions between second or
>      third parties, potentially involving non-related resources and to deny
>      and/or withdraw number registration services on that basis.  This does
>      not sound legally enforceable.
> 
> No, it is not a matter of parties. It is a matter of the membership rules.

Jordi, you need to take legal advice on this before proceeding further.

Nick