[address-policy-wg] 2016-03 New Version and Impact AnalysisPublished (Locking Down the Final /8 Policy)

>> I'm of the second group. For me the IPs is something that is lend to me 
>> to do my work and not to trade them.

This is the main idea behind the public IP addresses, according to IANA.
I've mentioned this before in a discussion regarding another policy.
PUBLIC IP addresses have given to us to use not to trade. We haven't paid 
for getting them, and we are not the owner.

Kind Regards,
Saeed.


-----Original Message----- 
From: listas at cutre.net
Sent: Thursday, October 20, 2016 10:12 AM
To: address-policy-wg at ripe.net
Subject: Re: [address-policy-wg] 2016-03 New Version and Impact 
AnalysisPublished (Locking Down the Final /8 Policy)

I think the problem in the end is how we consider what is an public IP 
prefix.

In my city (Madrid, Spain, if you have curiosity, welcome to the city 
hosting RIPE 73), we have taxis. A license to have a taxi is assigned for 
life and when the owner retires, he can sell it for whatever he wants and 
the market is able to pay. Of course the number of licenses is limited.

We have also a electric car sharing system (car2go) that allow you to rent a 
car and pay for its usage. When the usage finish, the user return the car, 
no money returned, can't "sell" it because is not the owner.
Of course the number of cars is limited.

Those are two views on how to manage scarce resources. For some people 
public IP allocation should follow the first method. More "capitalist" it 
can be said, for others, the second, more "social", is the best.

I'm of the second group. For me the IPs is something that is lend to me to 
do my work and not to trade them.

Some time ago (before the last /8) I worked with a company that in one 
moment didn't need anymore their IPs (mother company delegated a range) so 
advised by me they returned them to RIPE and closed the LIR.

That's how I see it.

Note: my mail is educated and don't address nobody personally. Please keep 
the conversation at the same level. Demonstrate you're respected engineers 
and not hooligans.


Enviado desde mi iPhone