[address-policy-wg] Splitting 2015-05 in two

On Tue, May 10, 2016, at 16:39, Niall O'Reilly wrote:
>   If it were my proposal, here's how I would go about it.
> 
>   Withdraw the current proposal.
>   The proposer can always do this during the process.
> 
>   Introduce two new proposals (2016-somenumber and 2016-someothernumber)
>   respectively containing the "Part A" and "Part B" material from the
>   current proposal.

Hello,

As the proposal was written, the "part B" (allocation condition
including v6 deployment) would have no sense on its own, since it only
applies to the results of "part A" (further allocations).
In order to have a "part B" that makes any sens, it would mean that
current rules for allocation of the "first /22 from last /8" would have
to change:
 - for a "real" first allocation (LIR that never received a v4
 allocation before) either conditions would not apply, or a new system
 would have to be created where the allocation is time-limited, and at
 the end of time limit the allocated block is either returned (condition
 not met) or made "regular allocation" (condition met).
 - for LIRs that had previously allocated IPv4 space, condition applied
 directly.