[address-policy-wg] agreement

> Yes they can, but if they are really interested to make their LIR job.
> If the only motivation of new-comers is to get some IPv4 as their internet
> service provider is not able to provide them with any, there would no do LIR
> job.  (new RIPE NCC members are not necessarily from IT industry and are
> forced to become LIR)
>

Why wouldn't a LIR get some space on the secondary market to provide to its
customers ?

> And you consider it fair when you cannot get more than /22 when some players
> have /19 or more?

For some definition of "fair".
I came to the game later when the pool was empty, I know it and I understand it.
So, I consider "fair" I was able to get a small part of IPv4 that helped me
kickstart the business.

> At the moment many new LIRs are just joining the RIPE NCC to get small blocks,
> that is happening.
>

Some are taking advantages of this situation (open multiple LIR) to get IPv4
space. I don't see how 2015-05 would stop that even if you allow new LIR to get
more than a /22. All I can see it more faster depletion (honest LIR getting
more + dishonest LIR getting more)

I hear your arguments but I don't think 2015-05 is the right answer for the
community.

Denis