[address-policy-wg] We need IPv4 transfers

On 1 Jul 2015, at 12:13, Shahin Gharghi <shahin at gharghi.ir> wrote:

> And I think you'd better play fair. You are using your
> power as a chair to get this proposal accepted.

This is utter nonsense.

> I asked a question and if you have an answer for that, tell me.
> People will be able to transfer their /22 after accepting this
> proposal. So this proposal won't help at all.

Yawn. The WG has discussed this at length. The time for that discussion is over. We're past that point in the PDP. The 2015-01 is now at the stage where the consensus determination is scrutinised or for any NEW issues to be raised. You're doing neither and it's not helpful.

> What's your answer as a person who supports this proposal and of
> course as the chair?

These questions are utterly inappropriate to this point of the PDP.

If you feel that there are NEW issues which have been overlooked, raise them. Don't re-hash the arguments that were made earlier. If you consider the consensus determination was somehow flawed, please explain how. These are the only options for where we are currently in the PDP for this proposal. Kindly respect that.

You are of course welcome to come forward with a new proposal in support of your PoV or to overturn an existing policy. The PDP machinery is open to all.