[address-policy-wg] 2014-02 New Draft Document and Impact Analysis Published (Allow IPv4 PI transfer)

Hello all,

The ability to transfer PI space is long awaited by the community, but I'm
a bit skeptical about it..

AFAIK there is a project active in RIPE NCC, which is about retrieving
unused PI space.
If I'm not wrong, that space is still reserved and in quarantine.
Wouldn't this policy change, affect the rate at which PI assignments are
returned to RIPE NCC?

I believe that the current "unofficial" PI space trade is because there is
no other way to get it legitimately.
Why not consider to re-allow PI assignments from the returned space,
instead of allowing PI transfers?
The unused PI space will eventually be returned to RIPE NCC, isn't it?

As I see it, this policy change rewards the end users who don't fulfill
their contractual obligations and don't return their unused PI space.
What would we say to those users who decided to honor their contract?

The only benefit I see is that more PI space will change hands, since the
end user has financial benefit to do that.
Of course that will lead to great de-aggregation and work load for the RIPE
NCC..

So, I don't agree nor oppose to this proposal yet.
I'll wait to see the comments of the rest in order to make my mind.

Regards,
George
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: </ripe/mail/archives/address-policy-wg/attachments/20140713/e1f4743b/attachment.html>