[address-policy-wg] RE: 2010-01 New Policy Proposal (Temporary Internet Number Assignment Policies)

Hi Nick and all,

You could well be right that "unfairness" could be exhibited by non-commercial organizations, in which case maybe removing the word "commercial" from the argument would be a good thing.

Kind regards
Jamie Stallwood

--
Jamie Stallwood
Security Specialist
Imerja Limited
Tel: 07795 840385
jamie.stallwood at imerja.com



-----Original Message-----
From: Nick Hilliard [mailto:nick at inex.ie]
Sent: Thu 5/6/2010 15:46
To: Jamie Stallwood
Cc: address-policy-wg at ripe.net
Subject: Re: [address-policy-wg] RE: 2010-01 New Policy Proposal (Temporary Internet Number Assignment Policies)
 
On 06/05/2010 00:32, Jamie Stallwood wrote:
> Today's discussion was interesting and concern was raised about
> commercials being able to get all or most of the address space set aside
> in the proposal, and about unfair commercial advantage. My thoughts as a
> paragraph, which I know is rushed and woolly and only intended as a
> discussion point:
> 
> 3.5 Use by Commercial Organizations
> Temporary address space will not be assigned by the RIPE NCC to any
> commercial organization where such an allocation:
> * Is not shown to be for a research, development or testing project
> relevant to an operational business of that organization
> * Does not seek to provide a "benefit", e.g. through published work in
> academic or industrial journals, or
> * Is unable to demonstrate a fair inclusion policy for other commercial
> organizations to contribute to, or benefit from, the project.

The original point about unfair advantage was purely that any organisation
(whether commercial or not) could hog all the address space in a temporary
assignment pool managed by the NCC, and that this would discriminate
against all other potential end users.

In the case of commercial end users, this discrimination could be
interpreted as a commercial advantage / disadvantage situation.

Can you explain why you're suggesting that commercial end users be
discriminated against in any future temporary assignment policy?

Nick


-- 

Imerja Limited
Tel: 0870 8611488 | Fax: 0870 8611489 | 24x7 ISOC: 0870 8611490 | Web: www.imerja.com

Registered Office: Paragon House, Paragon Business Park, Chorley New Road, Horwich, Bolton BL6 6HG

Registered in England and Wales No. 5180119
VAT Registered No. 845 0647 22
ISO Registered Firm No. GB2001527

This email is confidential and intended solely for the person or 
organisation to which it is addressed. It may contain privileged and 
confidential information. If you are not the intended recipient(s) you
should not use, copy, distribute or take any action or reliance on it,
since to do so is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. If you have
received this transmission in error please notify the sender 
immediately by email reply and delete it from your system. E-mail 
messages are not secure and attachments could contain software viruses
which may damage your system. Whilst every reasonable precaution has
been taken to minimise this risk, Imerja Limited cannot accept any
liability for any damage sustained as a result of these factors. You
are advised to carry out your own virus checks before opening any
attachment. Any views or opinions expressed in this e-mail are solely
those of the author and do not represent those of Imerja Limited 
unless otherwise stated.

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: </ripe/mail/archives/address-policy-wg/attachments/20100506/b404ba0b/attachment.html>