[address-policy-wg] what to do about 2009-01?

On Wed, Apr 14, 2010 at 12:14:38PM +0100, Jim Reid wrote:

> 1) Withdraw 2009-01. It's dead. Heroic measures to revive it and  
> achieve a global policy are not going to have a happy outcome. So  
> accept that situation and give up.

sounds reasonable, but it has the downside of not making an assessment of
the merits of the proposal as well as delivering the second bullet.

> 2) Continue with 2009-01 with a view to aligning things with the other  
> RIRs except ARIN. Perhaps that might persuade ARIN to reconsider. It's  

It's always easy to approve of something that you know doesn't come into
effect.  So, if the community really wants this option, we better assume
it be implemented sooner or later _and_ emphasize the commitment by
appropriate communication outside the PDP process.

-Peter