[address-policy-wg] Policy Proposal : "Run Out Fairly"

On 07.04 14:02, Filiz Yilmaz wrote:
> ...
> 
> In ARIN, there is a proposal called "Depleted IPv4 reserves".
> It is proposing to set a limit to be applied to all IPv4 address  
> requests when ARIN's reserve of unallocated IPv4 address space drops  
> below an equivalent of /9. By then, the address space that an  
> organisation can receive will be limited to a single /20 within a six  
> month period.
> 
> This is currently under discussion and you can find further details at:
> 
> https://www.arin.net/policy/proposals/2009_2.html

While similar this appears to be  a transition/new entrant reservation.
It is orthogonal to "Run Out Fairly".

> -o-
> 
> In APNIC, they have discussed two proposals in their last meeting back  
> in February. One of them was to change the timeframe APNIC uses to  
> make IPv4 allocations to meet LIRs' needs from twelve months to six  
> months. The other was to set a maximum APNIC allocation size, by  
> gradually decrease the maximum allocation size based on the remaining  
> number of /8s in the IANA free pool.
> 
> Both of these proposals were abandoned after APNIC 27, following a  
> lack of community support.
> You can still find their details at:
> 
> http://www.apnic.net/policy/proposals/prop-063-v002.html
> http://www.apnic.net/policy/proposals/prop-070-v001.html

These were the discussions I referred to.
Note that one of the auhors of "Run Out Fairly" plays some
role in the APNIC policy sig. ...

> -o-
> 
> LACNIC has reached consensus back in 2008 on a proposal called  
> "Special IPv4 Allocations/Assignments Reserved for New Members".  
> Accordingly when IANA's pool of IPv4 addresses is exhausted and LACNIC  
> has a /12 left in their pool, only new members will receive address  
> space from LACNIC. This space will be a /24 as the minimum and a /22  
> as the maximum. They have further detailed criteria and you can see  
> them at:
> 
> http://lacnic.net/documentos/politicas/LAC-2008-04-propuesta-en.pdf

Again more of a transition/new entrant reservation.