[address-policy-wg] 2007-01 Last Call for Comments (Direct Internet Resource Assignments to End Users from the RIPE NCC)

Le mardi 08 avril 2008 à 05:29 -0700, Leo Vegoda a écrit :
> Hi Frederic,
> 
> On 08/04/2008 03:58, "Frederic" <frederic at placenet.org> wrote:
> 
> [...]
> 
> > why is broken ? because Ripe do not implement relation between PI holder
> > thru Database information.
> >
> > Dead PI is like Dead Domain name.
> 
> This is a fairly good analogy. My understanding of domain names is that they
> are normally delegated according to a contract with a registry or registrar.
> If the contract ends the delegation is removed.
> 
> > a simple procedure thru mail communication can force to have news about
> > "may be Dead" block and take the good decision.
> >
> > To force "Contractual Link with Ripe" for PI bloc is not the good way.
> > To force Fees is not good too.
> 
> I pay small fees for the domains I have registered.
> 
> Is your opposition to this proposal based on the size of the fee or are you
> opposed to there being any fees at all?
> 

1) first i talk about domain for the way to check if is still alive: you
receive one mail, two.... before is deleting. and you pay where you want
your domain, you have a lot of choice.

Some domain are free and you have choice to use it
(eu.org, .st, .nf....)


About fees:
When a real work is done , is normal to pay for is work. (and the amount
is equal to the effort and time to made this work...).


About:
IANA -> RIPE NCC -> LIR -> PI recipient
and may be 
IANA -> RIPE NCC -> PI recipient

the probleme (and is a political problem) is to have choice.

We support to have contractual link with the compagny that you decide
for PI.

request must be free (and free of tax ;).

In our non profit company, we talk about Ipv6. and we "do not
understand" why assignement are different that Ipv4. why is not possible
when you have Ipv4-Pi to request right now Ipv6-PI.

"do not understand" = we understand the process, the ripe policy etc...
but we do not understand why Pa assignement are available, not PI. (the
answer was : we must go to policy proposal mailing list of ripe ;)

bst regards.
Frederic



> Regards,
> 
> Leo Vegoda
>