[address-policy-wg] Re: [ncc-services-wg] Request Forms: upda ted and available on LIR Portal

Hi,

Ludger Bornhorst is on vacation but we have discussed this matter before he send this mail.
Here two notes from my point of view:

you wrote: The RIR->LIR level has the AW to express a given level of trust.

I quite agree with you: You could use policies in a narrow interpretation or
in a scope of interpretation in addition with your know how in cases of
ip-address management, both is possible and essential. But you couldn't find
this scope in ripe-283 e.g. #[EQUIPMENT DESCRIPTION]#, I think that's the problem.
Or is this scope in addition to your AW an unwritten policy? 

you wrote: please don't feed the buerocracy.

I can assure you that's not our target. From our point of view policies should
give all parties, here the LIR's, a general Framework and not a straitjacket.

mit freundlichen Grüßen/with best regards

Klaus Kinder
_________________________________________

Deutsche Telekom
T-Com Headquarters
Network Information Center
Local Internet Registry
Ammerländer Heerstr. 138, D-26129 Oldenburg
+49 441 234 - 4530 (phone)
+49 441 234 - 4589 (fax)
E-Mail: Klaus.Kinder at telekom.de